GM70 Dual mono block amplifier. Parafeed and Sakuma principle.
* RELEASED *
Some words about Mr. SAKUMA (picture below)
The Japanese Designer SAKUMA, is famous for driving transmitter tubes like 845 or 211 with the same tube, to cancel harmonics. Mr. Susumu Sakuma has published this method in Japan in the 1980's, and later in Sound Practices in 1997.
Mr. Sakuma is not the inventor of this, I have found the theory also in the "Ratheiser" of 1950. Yet, Mr. Sakuma was the first who made use of this for HiFi. Also in the books of Rainer zur Linde, I found an interesting explanation of this harmonics canceling theory, using AD1 tubes in his examples. Yet it can be used on any Triode, but best result you will have with directly heated triodes.
I prefer to call this method, the "Sakuma" Method, though the word is chosen by myself, in honor to Mr. Sakuma's many and beautiful designs. I can not explain it quickly in a few words here, but I will try. I did not believe it at first, because the theory seems unusual. Then, from measurements, I can confirm: It works indeed!
You do need basic understanding of what distortion is. First, there is linear distortion, this is what a tone control will do. Such distortion can be reversed. So one part of the signal chain may add some high frequency, but you can remove that with a simple network. Second, there is non-linear distortion. This is trouble, because it means adding frequencies to the signal that were not there before. Once a frequency is added, it is not possible to remove it any more. The added frequencies we call harmonics, because they appear as nice multiples. So if we distort a tone of 1000Hz, frequencies of 2000, 3000, 4000, etc will be added. So this is non-linear distortion, and the added frequencies are the harmonics. Until a small level, the even harmonics are no problem. Though they are not desirable. The uneven harmonics sound always bad to the human ear. So keep in mind: Non-Linear distortion (the kind that sounds bad) is adding harmonics to the signal.
What can we do against distortion?
The most commonly used method is negative feedback, because it works well, and it is cost efficient. However, this makes the amplifier also sound sterile, or let's say more like a transistor amplifier. Reason is simply, negative feedback removes everything which comes from the amplifier itself. So really all that is left, is the output signal = Gain x Input signal. Whereas a non feedback amplifier has a lot of (very complex) interaction of the loudspeaker chassis with the power tubes, via the transformer, where energy is not only going from the amplifier in the speakers, but also energy from the speakers can be dumped in the tubes. This, and many more elements make the non-feedback sound. Also driver tubes and pre-amplifier tubes add their specific own components, called harmonics.
What is negative feedback? Basically you need to look at it like this: If you have an amplifier End Stage without feedback, of course it will have some distortion. Now, suppose you have a way to add a signal to the input, same as the distortion component (the error component) but in anti phase, then of course the distortion would be gone. The simplest way is by deriving the Error from the signal output, invert it, and feed it back into the input. Then it is called negative feedback. It is beyond the subject here to explain it in detail, as this amplifier is zero feedback anyway.
Another method to reduce distortion is generate the required Error signal with dedicated electronics, and then it is called compensation. This is what we are doing here. Compensation is more complicated, but then you don't have the disadvantages of negative feedback. The method of Mr. Sakuma is a very effective way with compensation. The theory is also explained in a German book by Rainer zur Linde †, called "Verstaerker in Roehrentechnik", ISBN Number 3-928051-02-4, and you find it on page 45.
To make it work almost ideal, I found the working point of the driver stage must be adjustable, in order to introduce exactly that amount of distortion which the End Stage also produces. Reason is, the driver stage works at lower signal, so without adjustment, distortion is not the same. You can adjust this working point by oscilloscope, or by hearing tests.
The whole end stage is duplicated, and in unchanged form it is used as driver stage. If the driver stage is used in anti phase with the output stage, this method is going to reduce even harmonics significantly. It will not reduce odd harmonics though. As directly heated triodes produce mainly even harmonics, this works really ideal with such tubes. For the theory part, with signal shape, etc, I would encourage you to read the theoretical part of Rainer zur Linde, but it is in German.
In a practical situation this works really beautiful, and when you make the distortion of the amplifier visible on an oscilloscope, or use a distortion meter, you can indeed see, there is one specific working point for the driver tube which results in extremely low harmonics for the whole amplifier. There are no other tubes for the whole amplifier, than just those two GM70 tubes.
The two stages of this amplifier are Parafeed configuration. This is not strictkly necessary for a Sakuma amplifier, but it I choose to do so for two good reasons, I will explain those here. All in all the design is nicely straight forward, and does immediately what we expect from it, without any surprizes or difficulties.
The First reason for arafeed: It splits the requirements for the SE transformer in two functions, that each device will do better. The Anode DC current is send into a choke, which has no other function than being a high impedance. The good thing is, it can be an unlinear (frequency dependant) impedance even. This doesn't matter. As long as the impedance is high, the anode choke is doing it's job, and it's only function is to absorb the DC current from the tube. The actual signal path is another. The signal transformation (in this case, impedance transformation) is done by a so called PPZ transformer. Such a transformer is like a PP transformer, but it has no air gap on purpose. This is where the "Z" comes from, it is means Zero air gap. Here comes the other merit of a Parafeed design. Normally there is always some unbalance in Push Pull stages, never both tubes used, have identical bias. This can be 15%. So, a good PP transformer will always have a (small) air gap still. Since we really completely take the DC path via the anode choke, there is no small DC current through our PP transformer any more. So we can go to zero air gap, and that way we will get much higher inductance, meaning the low frequency range gets significantly better. This may seem so simple to say. However it means we can with the SAME performance, use a transformer of smaller dimensions, and this is exactly what GM70 needs. This is a transmitter tube, similar but larger and better than the 211 (VT4C) tube. Such tubes suffer from primary windings capacitance always. So the smaller the transformer, the lower the windings capacitance And yes, with parafeed it can be made smaller! We have no DC component, forcing use to take a huge core, which would only make the copper wire longer, the windings larger diameter, and simply more windings capacitance. With PPZ we don't have this problem. So we can use the medium size transformer LL1679-PPZ for the output, and as interstage we can conveniently use the almost fragile looking type LL1660-PPZ, though we use such a massive tube like GM70 to drive it.
So to say it in other words, PPZ is specially made for parafeed applications. This PPZ signal transformer is now freed from the DC current, and will reward for this with very low distortion, and a wider frequency range, when compared with the same transformer with air gap.
Moreover, voltage capability of a transformer increases very much when the air gap is removed, and in fact we are now using it at much lower saturation. Versus SE transformers which are always used close to saturation limits, as the DC current gives enormous pre-magnetisation to the core.
In a nutshell, the above is the advantage of parafeed. The disadvantage, if you want to say so, is the need for an additional Anode choke.
The second reason for using parafeed here, is to stay in line with the Sakuma principle. Now, we can elegantly duplicate the complete output stage without any change, and we use it as a driver stage. This is the principle, so drive a triode stage by a stage of similar construction. By this, we can be sure, the distortion behavior as identical to the end stage, but.... in anti-phase, so total distortion of the two whole amplifier will be low.
The total gain needed, is also produced by the input transformer and interstage transformer, which produce gain as well, but at much lower distortion than a tube, and virtually noise free and virtually microphonics free. This works very satisfactory because of the low plate impedance of the GM70. Interesting, plate impedance at lower voltage becomes lower than normal for the GM70.
We all together, we use the Sakuma principle here, driving a GM70 with a GM70. This design is extensively tested and build as final version too. This amplifier produces a healthy 10 Watts per channel. The choice was not to go for highest possible power with small component count. So any of you who are satisfied with the output power of a 300B amplifers, but looking for this sweet, silky sound of those high impedance thoriated Tungsten tubes.... here is a very nice amplifier with the GM70. Output power with 2x 10 Watt is higher as some 300B amplifiers, and the output power can be increased significantly and easily, without having to change the transformers. Even the mains transformer needs to to be changed. Only the capacitors must be adapted, for the higher voltages used. It is recommended to build it first as 2x 10 Watt amplifier.
If you want to re-build this nice amplifier, please contact us. We give a some l discount on all amplifier kits like this. This is a very good working, tested design, but we have only for sale the main components. So not the resistors, and also not the mains transformer. For the rest, most other parts we have..
The power Supply
we are using mercury rectifiers in here. These light up beautiful, and also are very well suited for high voltage and high current at the same time. Actually producing a rectified almost 1kV with normal (Barium Coated) rectifiers is not really easy to do. Besides mercury rectifiers are virtually indestructible, vs. (Barium Coated) rectifiers are kind of sensitive and difficult to use at such high voltage and such high current at the same time, so we would end up with heavier types like Television booster diodes or similar. The choice was for those nice Mercury rectifiers. Such types like 866A can be found still as NOS, at reasonable prices, so when you like tube rolling, this is a good choice.
When using Mercury rectifiers, you need to know they need some special attention. Before applying high voltage to them, they need to be fully warmed up. Even though they seem to work "cold" as well, it's wrong to do, and it written so in their data sheet not to do this.
For warming them up, the easiest way is use a separate (small) transformer for their heaters only. Then, switching this transformer on the primary side is a convenient way to switch the heaters. Otherwise, using just one transformer, means you need a relay to switch 900 Volts DC, which is a very large and difficult relay. Or a solid state relay perhaps, but all in all this becomes a strange and not nice solution. Wheras a small transformer just for the 866 heaters is not expensive, and when we make this choice anyway, we can let the other heaters run on the same transformer also. Now we can even pre-heat the GM70's, which will reward you with better lifetime.
Un boxing NOS 866.
When you take NOS 866a out of the box, you will see there is not much Mercury inside, perhaps a little trace here and there, but the glass is shiny and clean. That is because the Mercury is still in the capsule. Such capsules were used in production, and it's just a little container with small holes in it, and inside is a large drop of Mercury. First time you switch them on, at first it's just a red glowing heater. But then, slowly the glass will get all shady with gray stuff. This is normal. So don't worry, this is the Mercury now evaporating from the capsule as it gets hot, and the Mercury condenses at the glass, the color is silvery. Then, after a few minutes, the glass begins to warm up too, and the Mercury that was on the glass, will evaporate as well. Now, the glass becomes clear again, after you see that, you may switch on the high voltage transformer, and burn-in of the new rectifier begins. After an hours or so, it is in maximum condition. Some are at maximum immediately, which is not better, just another way they are.
For switching off the amplifier, you can do something nice for your GM70, to enlarge their lifetime. First you switch off the high voltage. After that the GM70 will cool down even though the heater is still running, it will become less hot without anode voltage. Then after that you switch off the heater as well, and the amp is switched off. This way to switch them off will keep the GM70 longer in good condition. Though lifetime of GM70 is exceptionally good anyway, this is always better for any tube.
Next time you switch on the amplifier, the 866a will again develop the shady glass, and you just wait a few minutes until it is one, and then you can switch on the high voltage. Note, that eventually the glass of the 866 will become a little bit unclean. It's not really dirty, but it's not completely clean any more. This is normal with Mercury rectifiers, as the Mercury will transport residual dirt that is inside the tube, to the glass. When the Mercury evaporates the dirt will stay on the glass, which is a much better place for that, than on any other (active) part of the tube. All on all, Mercury rectifiers are great products, and the most reliable tube diodes that excists.
Here comes one disadvantage: They get into conductive state with a negative resistance curve. This results in relatively sharp switching on, when you use very large first capacitors, and it's the reason for disappointing results when designers are not aware of this. This can create some higher order noise hum. So, no dark sounding 50 (or 60) Hz, but higher order products like 100Hz, 150Hz, 200Hz. etc. To prevent this, the first capacitor is chosen quite small. The power supply is more regarded like an L-C power supply, as the C-L-C which you might expect at a first glance.
To prevent any hum, we have used a great option of the Lundahl transformers, as these all have a double coil. The power supply output is completely inductively separated from the rest of the circuit. If you look at the power supply schematic, you see this blue dotted line. There is no direct copper wire connection from the outputs to the rectifier tubes, you always need to pass an inductor. So there is no way out for the hum signal of the rectifiers. The power supply becomes dead-quiet.
VOLTAGE and Output power
The relatively small value of the first capacitor, allows you to adjust the effective output voltage within remarkably wide range. This amplifier was made for 920Volts, though we all know GM70 can run on 2300Volts also. For your safety, keep in mind already 920Volts may not be very forgiving when you touch it by mistake. Also for this reason, do not boost the voltage from the beginning. Yet, the power supply can be raised later to approximately 1150Vols, by only t increasing the first capacitor that comes after the 866 rectifiers. Note, as a result, some other capacitors, including the parafeed coupling capacitors must work on 1150V then also. If you do, it will enable an estimated 20 Watts per channel. This option is unsupported and untested, but it is anticipated to be possible.
it is assumed you are experienced in designing amplifiers with lethal voltages, and you are legally qualified to do so. This is no project for beginners. All we supply you here are schematics at your own risk and responsibility. This is no instruction of how to build a high voltage amplifier in a SAFE way. This knowledge you need to have yourself.
The picture you see here, is by Philippe M. from Switzerland.
SOME SIMILAR PROJECTS FROM JAPAN